Workshops and Annual
Conference
Pricing Tests for Commodity Bundles
- Workshop
Thursday April 3, 14.00-18.00 hrs, The Hague, OPTA
Many products and services are produced with common costs and sold
in bundles. It is often difficult - and sometimes impossible - to
allocate total fixed costs of production to the various components
of a commodity bundle. It is often rational, both for a dominant
supplier and for its rivals, to offer substitutes and complements
with implicit cross-subsidization. For a regulator, offerings above
incremental costs but below total average costs may appear predatory
- which they certainly can be, but not always.
The complexity of pricing tests for commodity bundles makes it difficult
to assess the competitive nature of observed pricing strategies,
creating a risk of errors in intervention. To correctly assess the
predatory nature of pricing, or attempts of price-squeeze, for example,
requires a good understanding of the component relations, the structure
of common costs and the ability of efficient rivals to replicate
specific product bundles. This often requires advanced economic
modelling and sophisticated empirical analysis.
In this workshop, ENCORE brings several leading practitioners together
to discuss the latest developments in pricing tests for commodity
bundles from both a legal and an economic point of view.
Contributors to this workshop are: Andrea Coscelli (CRA International),
Peter Eijsvoogel (Allen & Overy) and Patrick Greenlee (US Department
of Justice). The workshop will be chaired by Maarten Pieter Schinkel
(ENCORE/ACLE).
For further information and registration,
click here.
Calling Party's Network Pays vs Bill
and Keep - Workshop
Tuesday April 22, 14.00 - 18.00 hrs, The Hague,
Koninklijke Schouwburg
In wholesale interconnection, two different payment systems exist:
the calling party's network pays (CPNP) system and the bill and
keep (BaK) system. Traditionally, telephone operators in the Netherlands
have used CPNP, which is also dominant in other European countries.
Under this system, the initiating operator pays the receiving operator
for terminating a call. At the retail level, CPNP is usually combined
with the calling party pays (CPP) system, under which the customer
that makes the call bears all the costs. Alternatively - as for
instance in US mobile telephony - operators interconnect on a BaK
basis. Under this latter system, there are no payments between the
operators. BaK is usually - but not necessarily - combined with
the receiving party pays (RPP) system at the retail level. Under
RPP, the costs of the call are divided amongst the calling and the
receiving customer.
The two systems appear to have importantly different implications.
BaK has been argued to stimulate competition between operators,
resulting in lower consumer prices. This, in turn, would reduce
the burden of regulatory agencies to monitor the markets for telephony
and other data traffic. On the other hand, there is indication that
CPNP creates more incentives to invest in maintaining and extending
networks.
In this ENCORE workshop, various aspects of the two alternative
payment systems are introduced and discussed by prominent contributors
to the international debate. After an introduction of the basic
concepts, there will be a presentation of theoretical and empirical
findings, after which an outlook will be sketched. Apart from telephony,
examples will be drawn from other forms of data traffic, most notably
the internet.
Contributors to this workshop are: Carlo
Cambini (Politecnico Turin), Stephen Littlechild (Cambridge University)
and Scott Marcus (WIK-Consult). The workshop will be chaired by
Stein Smeets (Dialogic).
For further information and registration,
click here.
29 May New Date ENCORE Annual Conference
"Competition and Media Markets"
Thursday May 29, Hilversum, Instituut voor
Beeld en geluid
The ENCORE Annual Conference has been rescheduled to Thursday May
29.
Key-note speakers to this year's Annual Conference will be:
Prof.dr. M. Peitz - University of Mannheim
Dr. G. Miersch - European Commission
More information will be available at the ENCORE-website soon.
|